Our Blog

When it comes to adding stylish, functional storage to your home, floating shelves are a go-to solution. They’re sleek, versatile, and can elevate any space—whether it’s a cozy kitchen, a minimalist living room, or a chic bathroom. But where should you turn to get the best bang for your buck? Two options stand out: J Thomas Home, a small business specializing in custom-made floating shelves, and IKEA, the global big-box retailer known for affordable, mass-produced furniture. 

Customization: Tailored vs. One-Size-Fits-All

One of the biggest differences between J Thomas Home and IKEA is customization. J Thomas Home crafts each floating shelf to order, giving you control over every detail. With a variety of wood types—like pine, poplar, alder, maple, walnut, and white oak—and a range of stains or unfinished options, you’re not just buying a shelf; you’re designing a piece that fits your space and style perfectly.

IKEA, on the other hand, sticks to a standardized approach. Their floating shelves, like the popular LACK or Bergshult series, come in fixed sizes, colors (mostly white, black, or basic wood tones), and designs. The embossed acrylic paint can fade and rub off though, showing the plastic edging, or particle board over time. This will make it more susceptible to damage from moisture, especially if in a bathroom, laundry room or kitchen. 

J Thomas Home’s approach ensures you get exactly what you need, since authentic wood improves with age. This also means that the finishes highlight the natural beauty of the authentic wood grain, whereas the IKEA wood-look versions are merely printed and embossed to imitate wood. This difference will be especially noticeable when placed next to high-quality cabinets or furniture.

Quality: Craftsmanship vs. Convenience

Quality is where J Thomas Home truly shines. These shelves are handcrafted in the USA by a team of skilled woodworkers in Olathe, KS, using premium, solid hardwoods. Each piece is carefully selected, cut, sanded, and finished with durable stains or clear coats, ensuring a refined texture and lasting beauty. This isn’t just a shelf; it’s an investment in heirloom-quality craftsmanship that’s built to endure.

IKEA’s floating shelves, while affordable, lean heavily on cost-cutting materials like particleboard or MDF (medium-density fiberboard), often coated with a veneer or laminate. These materials are lighter and cheaper but lack the durability and natural charm of solid wood. For a minimalist display of lightweight trinkets, they might suffice, but for anything more substantial, their quality falls short. J Thomas Home’s superior materials and construction offer better value by delivering a product that doesn’t need replacing in a few years. That also means the shelves can be refinished years down the road if updates are made through the years.

Value: Price vs. Longevity

At first glance, IKEA’s price tags are hard to beat. A basic LACK shelf might run you $20-$30, while J Thomas Home’s custom shelves start closer to $100, depending on size and wood type. But value isn’t just about the upfront cost—it’s about what you get for your money over time. IKEA’s low price reflects its mass-production model, designed for quick assembly and broad appeal. However, the trade-off is a shorter lifespan and less flexibility. If you need to replace an IKEA shelf after a few years of wear or because it doesn’t quite fit your evolving needs, those savings erode fast.

J Thomas Home, by contrast, offers shelves that are built to last decades, not just seasons. The ability to customize means you’re not stuck with a shelf that’s “close enough”—you get one that’s perfect from day one. Plus, their focus on real wood and robust brackets ensures they can handle heavier loads and daily use without buckling. Add in the aesthetic upgrade of natural wood grain over laminate, and you’re paying for a piece that enhances your home’s character, not just its storage. Over time, J Thomas Home’s shelves prove more cost-effective because they outlast and outperform their IKEA counterparts.

The Personal Touch: Small Business vs. Corporate Giant

There’s something special about buying from J Thomas Home that IKEA can’t replicate: the human connection. Founded by husband-and-wife duo Josh and Emily Lorg, J Thomas Home is a small business with a passion for woodworking and customer satisfaction. IKEA, while efficient, is a corporate behemoth where customization and personalized service simply aren’t part of the equation. 

For a truly custom designer look, J Thomas home shelves can be ordered unfinished. This allows them to be stained or painted on-site to match kitchen cabinets, flooring, and other design elements. The result is a seamless, high-end finish tailored to your space. In contrast, IKEA’s limited selection doesn’t offer this level of flexibility or customization.

The Verdict

So, which offers the best value on floating shelves? If you’re after the cheapest option for a temporary fix, IKEA might do the trick. But for anyone who prioritizes quality, customization, and durability, J Thomas Home is the clear winner. Custom-made, solid wood shelves deliver a level of craftsmanship and versatility that IKEA’s mass-produced alternatives can’t match. Yes, you’ll pay more upfront, but you’ll get a product that fits your space, lasts longer, and looks better doing it. In the battle of value, J Thomas Home proves that true worth lies in quality and care—not just a low price tag.

Looking to add wooden wall shelves to your home? Contact J Thomas Home and get started today!